Your Appeal Is Your Last Best Chance To Right A Wrong

Photo of Scott M. Davidson

Representation when appealing a conviction in New Mexico

On Behalf of | May 17, 2024 | New Mexico State Criminal Appeals

Facing a criminal conviction can be a devastating experience. However, the legal system offers the possibility of an appeal, a chance to challenge a verdict and potentially achieve a more just outcome.

If you’re considering appealing a conviction in New Mexico, a crucial decision you’ll face is whether to retain your original legal team or seek new representation.

Understanding the appeals process

Appeals differ significantly from trials. The focus shifts from presenting evidence and witness testimony to scrutinizing the legal proceedings of the original trial. Appellate courts primarily look for errors made by the judge or prosecution that could have unfairly influenced the outcome. This necessitates a strong grasp of legal procedure and appellate arguments.

Benefits of keeping your trial legal team

There are advantages to sticking with your existing legal team. Familiarity with your case is a major asset. Your team already understands the details of your case. This can save valuable resources in getting up to speed on the appeal. Additionally, a strong working relationship built during the trial can translate into effective collaboration during the appeal.

Reasons to consider new representation

While continuity can be beneficial, there are also reasons to consider a new legal representative. Perhaps your trial legal team has limited experience with appeals. Appeals require a specific skill set, and a legal team with a track record of success can help you navigate this complex legal process.

Assessing your original representation

If you’re unsure about your trial legal team’s qualifications, consider these factors:

  • Communication Style: Did you feel comfortable and informed throughout the trial process? Open communication is even more crucial during an appeal.
  • Confidence in appealing: Does your current team express confidence in handling the appeal and clearly explain the potential outcomes?

Remember, even if you decide to keep your trial legal team, personalized legal feedback from a new legal team can be insightful. They can offer a second opinion on the viability of your appeal and identify potential legal arguments your current team might have overlooked.

While keeping your trial legal team offers continuity, their experience with appeals is paramount. Evaluate your current team’s qualifications and consider consultations with a new legal representative, if necessary. By carefully weighing your options, you can secure the best possible representation for your appeal.